By Harry Mottram: Back in September 2025 councillors at Cheddar Parish Council made a number of objections to Lidl building a supermarket at the top of New Road. One which may not of caught the eye at the time was about bats and wildlife in general. Their minutes read: “Development is in a bat conservation area, is visible from the surrounding National Landscapes and close to the SSSI raising environmental concerns especially with the increase in emissions, sound, lighting and lorry deliveries in a sensitive ecological area.”
Most objections have been about whether there is a need for a supermarket between Cheddar and Axbridge since there are several grocers within a couple of miles and also about traffic congestion. Clearly Cheddar Parish Council knew their stuff as planners have cited regulations governing the ‘Conservation of Habitats and Species Regulations’ of 2017 which would put pressure on the homes of great crested newts, hazel dormice, and other unnamed reptiles (but perhaps small lizards and snakes). And Somerset Council planners also mention the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981 which covers birds, animals, wild plants and so forth – but despite various posts on local social media sites there is no mention of bats although as Cheddar Parish Council mention it is in a bat conservation area.

Planners also raised other objections which mainly refer to trees but also to the overall impact on the environment of the planned supermarket. They said: “The submitted Biodiversity Net Gain information contains inconsistencies between the biodiversity metric calculations, habitat plans, arboricultural information and landscape proposals, including discrepancies relating to existing and proposed trees and the strategic significance attributed to habitats within the biodiversity metric.
“As a consequence, the Local Planning Authority is unable to verify the baseline biodiversity value of the site, the post-development biodiversity value, or whether the development is capable of delivering the statutory biodiversity gain objective. It has therefore not been demonstrated that the proposal complies with the requirements of Schedule 7A of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990.”

What happens now? Lidl – or rather their representatives have a number of options. Putting in an appeal – usually within a time limit is the most obvious one as they can claim planners have got things wrong. The more likely route is to take into account the objections and redesign their plans – which in this case could include a dedicated wildlife zone, the planting of more trees and conserving the ‘existing trees’ so as to answer County’s objections. Or of course they could simply abandon the plans and walk away from the project – but having put in a lot of work and money to get approval that may seem unlikely.
Owned by the German based Schwarz Group the supermarket chain has announced it will be opening more than 50 new stores in the next 12 months as part of a £600million investment in its British infrastructure. It already has more than 1,000 stores in the UK with many more overseas in a multi-billion-pound operation – having moved up to be Britain’s fifth largest grocery chain after Tesco, Sainsbury’s, Asda and Aldi – overtaking Morrisons in the recent past.

Residents in Cheddar and Axbridge have taken to social media to voice their thoughts – and the views are split. Many see Lidl as a budget housekeeping option compared to nearby Sainsbury’s in Cheddar, the Co-op in Axbridge, the small Tesco near KOW, and the shops at the fuel station at ‘the Magic Roundabout’ and Tweentown. Others are not happy due to the lack of pedestrian and safe cycling access to the proposed store but also the congestion which is already chronic at times on the road. Now it is up to Lidl to decide what they want to do – but for the moment, the newts and dormice can continue their existence in the fenced off site.
For the record this is the full written decision by planners:
1
In the absence of sufficient information to exclude an adverse effect on the integrity of the North Somerset and Mendip Bats SAC beyond reasonable scientific doubt, the Council, as competent authority, is unable to adopt the conclusions of the submitted shadow Habitat Regulations Assessment or reach a favourable Appropriate Assessment. The proposal is therefore contrary to Regulation 63 of the Conservation of Habitats and Species Regulations 2017 (as amended), Policies D20 and D23 of the Sedgemoor Local Plan 2011-2032, and Policies N2 and N6 of the National Planning Policy Framework (2026).
2
In accordance with ODPM Circular 06/2005, relevant case law and national planning guidance, the potential effects on protected species must be adequately considered prior to determination. Insufficient information has been provided in respect of great crested newts to support either District Level Licensing or an alternative licensing route; hazel dormice to establish likely absence or adequately assess impacts and mitigation on the assumption of presence; and reptiles to reliably establish the assemblage and population affected and demonstrate appropriate avoidance, mitigation and compensation. In addition, the ecological implications of the pre-application habitat clearance have not been adequately accounted for. The LPA cannot therefore adequately discharge its duties in respect of these protected species, having regard to the Conservation of Habitats and Species Regulations 2017 (as amended), the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981, the Council’s biodiversity duty and Policy D20 of the Sedgemoor Local Plan 2011-2032 and Policy N2 of the NPPF.
3
The submitted Biodiversity Net Gain information contains inconsistencies between the biodiversity metric calculations, habitat plans, arboricultural information and landscape proposals, including discrepancies relating to existing and proposed trees and the strategic significance attributed to habitats within the biodiversity metric. As a consequence, the Local Planning Authority is unable to verify the baseline biodiversity value of the site, the post-development biodiversity value, or whether the development is capable of delivering the statutory biodiversity gain objective. It has therefore not been demonstrated that the proposal complies with the requirements of Schedule 7A of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990.
Axbridge Diary of Events
Some Axbridge dates coming up at https://www.harrymottram.co.uk/diary/

Harry Mottram
Note: I get asked this frequently so just to repeat I write up these stories from time to time out of personal interest – all the information is in the public domain – I put it together, so it makes sense to me. I’ve always taken an interest in local affairs having worked as a journalist in Somerset for many years. More at at www.harrymottram.co.uk and social media on X as @harrythe spiv, Facebook, Blue Sky, LinkedIn, Instagram, Threads and God knows where else!

You must be logged in to post a comment.